Bridging the Truth Gap: Rings of Power & Political Lessons

Fantasy as a Bridge

As a lifelong fan of fantasy, I’ve always believed that the stories we cherish hold lessons for the real world. In the spirit of bridging the gap between political ideologies, I’m starting with my fellow fantasy nerds and geeks. J.R.R. Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings offers profound insight into our current struggles, especially the idea behind the Rings of Power.

One ring represents absolute power, corrupting its bearer. Two rings lead to endless division and war. But three rings achieve balance, working together to preserve harmony. Today, America finds itself trapped in the chaos of two rings—each side locked in its truth, unable to see the other. To move forward, we must strive for the wisdom of the three rings.

Using the framework of “Honesty of the Situation” (HOTS), let’s examine ten pressing issues, reflect on their complexities, and explore how to move toward balance.

1. Russian Collusion Allegations

  • One Ring: Assuming Trump is entirely guilty or innocent.
  • Two Rings: Using foreign influence claims to fuel partisan warfare.
  • Three Rings: Acknowledging the bipartisan threat of foreign interference and collaborating to secure elections.

2. Sexual Misconduct Allegations

  • One Ring: Oversimplifying political choices based solely on personal conduct.
  • Two Rings: Condemning opponents for their candidate’s actions while ignoring similar failings in one’s own party.
  • Three Rings: Holding leaders accountable across the board while understanding voter priorities.

3. Vaccine Mandates

  • One Ring: Enforcing mandates without addressing public fears.
  • Two Rings: Polarizing the debate between “pro-vaccine” and “anti-vaccine” camps.
  • Three Rings: Building trust and promoting public health through transparency.

4. Election Integrity

  • One Ring: Viewing elections as completely secure or fraudulent.
  • Two Rings: Weaponizing election legitimacy for political gains.
  • Three Rings: Creating bipartisan reforms to restore public trust.

5. Immigration Policy

  • One Ring: Framing immigration as “open borders” versus “build the wall.”
  • Two Rings: Using immigration to stoke cultural fears.
  • Three Rings: Balancing border security with compassion and economic realities.

6. Climate Change

  • One Ring: Ignoring economic impacts for radical environmental changes.
  • Two Rings: Allowing the debate to devolve into “alarmists” vs. “deniers.”
  • Three Rings: Innovating solutions that address environmental and economic concerns.

7. Supreme Court Battles

  • One Ring: Treating the Court as a partisan tool.
  • Two Rings: Engaging in endless ideological warfare over appointments.
  • Three Rings: Supporting constitutional integrity over partisanship.

8. Media Bias

  • One Ring: Consuming only media that aligns with personal beliefs.
  • Two Rings: Living in echo chambers that polarize communities.
  • Three Rings: Promoting media literacy and consuming diverse viewpoints.

9. Policing and Justice Reform

  • One Ring: Viewing police as either irredeemable villains or untouchable heroes.
  • Two Rings: Entrenching “defund” vs. “back the blue” rhetoric.
  • Three Rings: Collaborating on reforms for accountability and safety.

10. Free Speech

  • One Ring: Demanding absolute freedom without consequences.
  • Two Rings: Fighting over censorship versus reckless expression.
  • Three Rings: Protecting free speech while fostering respectful dialogue.

The Final Challenge: Overcoming Laziness

As we work to move from division to balance, we must confront a critical obstacle: the laziness of passion. Passion often clouds judgment and leads to:

  1. Lazy Scrutiny: Demonizing opponents while excusing one’s own side.
  2. Lazy Relationships: Severing ties over disagreements instead of fostering understanding.
  3. Lazy Belief Systems: Clinging to unexamined truths.
  4. Lazy Accountability: Refusing to hold one’s own leaders to the same standards.

For example, those who condemned Trump as a threat to democracy must now grapple with President Biden potentially pardoning his son—an act many feared Trump would commit. The sin of power abuse, once denounced as unthinkable, becomes excusable when it’s “our side.”

Conclusion: Bridging the Gap

Fantasy stories teach us that balance, not domination, is the key to lasting harmony. The Rings of Power remind us that absolute truth is elusive, division is destructive, and balance is achievable only through humility, accountability, and empathy.

As Tolkien wrote, “Even the smallest person can change the course of the future.” Let us choose to bridge the gap, challenge our assumptions, and find the strength of spirit to build a better tomorrow—together.

Back to blog

Leave a comment