Controversy Erupts Over Muslim Song at Ottawa Remembrance Day
Share
Controversy Erupts Over Muslim Song at Ottawa Remembrance Day: Why Timing Matters
On November 11, 2024, Sir Robert Borden High School in Ottawa became the center of controversy after including the Arabic-language song “Haza Salam” (“This is Peace”) in their Remembrance Day program. The song, known for promoting peace and unity, also carries associations with political struggles in the Middle East, and its use on a day meant to honor Canadian veterans and fallen soldiers ignited backlash among students, parents, and community members.
Principal Aaron Hobbs quickly apologized, explaining that the song was intended to convey a message of peace. However, the response underscored a growing frustration with decisions perceived as “woke” that some Canadians feel compromise the solemnity of national traditions. The incident serves as a stark reminder: while messages of peace are valuable, their timing and setting are crucial—especially on a day dedicated to those who served and sacrificed for Canada.
Understanding “Haza Salam”: Origins and Context
"Haza Salam," which translates to “This is Peace,” is an Arabic song often used to convey resilience and unity in the face of hardship. Originally performed by artists such as Mahim Ahmed and Maryam Shihab, the song falls under the genre of nasheed, a type of Islamic vocal music known for its focus on moral and spiritual themes. While the song’s lyrics call for peace, they have also become intertwined with expressions of solidarity in the Middle East, specifically among communities affected by the Palestinian conflict.
Although “Haza Salam” does not contain overtly political lyrics, its association with Middle Eastern struggles, especially during times of active conflict, brings added sensitivity to its use. In this case, its inclusion on Remembrance Day—a day dedicated to honoring Canadian veterans—was seen by many as both out of place and potentially inflammatory.
Remembrance Day: A Day for Canadian Veterans
Remembrance Day is a solemn Canadian tradition focused on honoring the sacrifices of Canadian soldiers, particularly those who died in combat. It is a day to reflect on the bravery, loss, and service that define Canada’s military history. Introducing a song with ties to a specific cultural and political struggle shifted the day’s focus and, to some, felt dismissive of the sacrifices made by Canadian veterans.
This incident highlights the need for sensitivity and a deep understanding of context when planning content for commemorative events. Using Remembrance Day to promote a message of peace from an external conflict risked overshadowing the contributions of Canadian veterans, for whom this day exists as a unique moment of national respect and reflection.
Political Consequences: How Missteps Fuel Polarization
For Canadians concerned about divisive politics and the rise of “Trumpism” in Canada, this misstep serves as a warning. In the U.S., the perception of “woke” actions that appear to disregard national values has contributed to a backlash that played a significant role in former President Donald Trump’s political resurgence. Trump capitalized on instances where American institutions seemed out of touch with national sentiment, especially when they strayed too far from traditional patriotic values.
The choice to include a Middle Eastern peace song on Remembrance Day, even with the best of intentions, risks fueling similar sentiments in Canada. By placing an emphasis on a message tied to another region’s struggles, it detracts from the day’s purpose and may intensify anti-immigration and anti-Muslim sentiments among some Canadians. This is precisely the type of incident that can bolster support for more extreme right-wing advocates who argue that Canadian traditions and values are being undermined.
Balancing Inclusivity and Tradition: Why Timing Matters
Promoting messages of peace and unity is essential in a free and diverse society. However, Remembrance Day is a specific occasion meant to honor those who served and sacrificed for Canada. When these sentiments are introduced into a national event with a dedicated purpose, they risk being viewed as politically insensitive, regardless of the intention behind them.
If there is a time to discuss global struggles and calls for peace, it’s during events that reflect Canada’s multicultural values and commitment to human rights—events like Canada Day, where a broad celebration of peace and diversity is more fitting. Choosing to introduce such a message on Remembrance Day risks diluting its significance and potentially offending those who value the day as a time to reflect solely on Canadian sacrifices.
Lessons for Moving Forward
The controversy surrounding Sir Robert Borden High School’s Remembrance Day assembly is a reminder that intention does not always equal impact. While the choice to include “Haza Salam” was meant to convey peace, the timing overshadowed its intended message and became a flashpoint for division. The lesson here is clear: tradition and respect for Canada’s unique commemorative days must be prioritized, especially when planning public events.
As Canada navigates the challenges of a multicultural society, ensuring that national traditions like Remembrance Day are handled with sensitivity can prevent misunderstandings and foster unity. Moving forward, let this serve as a call for thoughtful planning, ensuring that the spirit of the day remains undisturbed while celebrating Canada’s diverse values at the right time.